Understanding, and Misunderstanding, Evil

Abby and I pose for a photo with our Chihuahuas, Sierra and Max, at the famous Welcome to Las Vegas sign in October 2011. Behind us is Mandalay Bay Hotel from which a gunman shot and killed 58 people and injured 530 more Sunday.
Abby and I pose for a photo with our Chihuahuas, Sierra and Max, at the famous Welcome to Las Vegas sign in October 2011. Behind us is Mandalay Bay Hotel from which a gunman shot and killed 58 people and injured 530 more Sunday.

There have been thousands or millions of opinions rendered since Sunday night’s mass shooting in Las Vegas. Virtually all of them have been vehement pronouncements of unassailable “truths”, such as, “This was an act of pure evil,” or, “this guy should burn in hell,” or, “we need gun control now,” or, “guns didn’t do this, a bad guy did it.”

Throughout history, human morality has been rife with immorality.
Throughout history, human morality has been rife with immorality.

They’re all wrong. I say this with a sense of irony, because I don’t know the right answer.

The problem comes from the obvious contradiction of “why,” which is a rational question asked of an irrational act. The easy, and useless, answer to “why” is that he was crazy or evil. If you found out that he was a white supremacist or an Islamic jihadist, it wouldn’t render his actions any less crazy or evil.

Until we can stop one-dimensionally hating the Las Vegas shooter (and all his ilk) and try to understand him, we are doomed to see him again and again. We can’t just write off these guys as “pure evil” without figuring them out. We have to shed this childish, “Why did the bad men fly the planes into the buildings, Daddy?” attitude.

One consistent fallacy in America is the idea that laws can deter immorality.
One consistent fallacy in America is the idea that laws can deter immorality.

Also along this line, at least one Christian leader blamed the shooting on our behavior, connecting religion, and therefore their god, to it.

“There is ‘violence in the streets,’ Pat Robertson said, because, ‘we have disrespected authority. There is profound disrespect for our president, all across this nation. They say terrible things about him. It’s in the news; it’s in other places.'” ~WP

One of the biggest obstacles to understanding irrational, seemingly evil acts, is our unwillingness, often terrified unwillingness, to admit we have that potential to go crazy or descend into evil ourselves. We all know it’s there because we all feel intense, blind rage at times, but many of us never really look in the mirrors of our souls.

Here are some additional observations about the current state of affairs…

  • Most people are not moral. Most people are self-serving.
  • Most people see the world in terms of a five mile radius and a 30-day billing cycle.
  • Most people who claim to believe in god do so because they think it will serve their causes, not because they honestly feel he is real. The rest believe it because they are told to do so.
  • Most people want money more than anything else.
  • Almost all people who type “prayers” or “praying” into comments on social media are not praying.
  • Professional athletes kneeling during the National Anthem is meaningless to me because I neither care about the opinions of professional athletes nor do I think they should be viewed as role models or heroes.
  • Most people are scared to death of almost everything every day, and though they would agree with this statement, they would say that it is “not me.”

Finally, there is a looming monster far more frightening than the wild card of angry lone nuts: North Korea. If you think 58 dead and 530 injured is a tragedy, you have forgotten the promise of the cold war: annihilation “like the world has never seen before,” at the hands of people far crazier and more evil than an angry nut with some AR15s.

The notion that innocence earns us a place without suffering is inherently flawed. "Deserve" has nothing to do with it. On the left is my grandfather Russell Barron, who was a good man his whole life, and whose life was spent in the terrible pain of arthritic disease.
The notion that innocence earns us a place without suffering is inherently flawed. “Deserve” has nothing to do with it. On the left is my grandfather Russell Barron, who was a good man his whole life, and whose life was spent in the terrible pain of arthritic disease.

4 Comments

  1. SO frakin’ agree about the innocence comments. People want to believe there’s a correlation between good behavior and protection from tragedy, and there just is not.

  2. Every time we have a mass murder, terrorists come out of the woodwork to claim they did it, and Christians come out of the woodwork to say God did it.

  3. A couple of points, just off the top of my head.

    1. I think that an investigation is underway right now to try and understand the “why” in this situation, but Paddock was apparently very good at concealing the “why” in his personal life. We might never know “why,” because he was, like all or most mass murderers, intensely private. I’m starting to rule out the possibility of a complete psychological understanding of this man because it simply might not be accessible, other than to say that he was, clearly, a sick, angry white American male with access to firearms.
    2. If he had been a brown-skinned foreigner with a beard, there would be all kinds of attempts to legislate/limit access to pretty much everything under the sun. Our orange-toned, fearless leader would be talking about “weighing all options” for an attack on a foreign land, and there would be more talk of banning people from certain nations. Not sure how we go about banning angry white Americans like Stephen Paddock, though. Hmmmmm ….
    3. He was an all-purpose killer, his victims other white Americans at a country music concert. I really would like to know what his beef was, except general homicidal rage toward humanity itself. If he had worked in a missile silo or on a nuclear sub, there is no doubt that right now, millions would be dead.
    4. How many more Stephen Paddocks are out there right now, working in missile silos and on nuclear subs? When do they throw their switch and start shooting out windows or punching buttons on launch systems?
    5. I made the mistake of watching a few conspiracy theorist videos this morning. One of them included an animated kitty cat calmly describing the massacre like it was Brian Williams or somebody. Via this eerie piece of animation, the crazies conspiracy theories were espoused, like, “nobody got shot,” “there was no blood,” “I ain’t seen no video of nobody with they head blowed off,” “false flag,” “the government did it,” “the media did it,” “nothing happened,” “the gunshots were played over the concert speakers,” and, of course, “there were no gunshots.” There is an enormous rabbit hole of insanity on the Internet. While agree that it is important to have a healthy skepticism, especially in this day and age, there is a HUGE difference between critical thinking and insanity. I’m fine with asking reasonable questions, but it is way too easy to go off the deep end and find “evidence” on the web that supports utter lunacy.

Comments are closed.